Israeli Patent Case Reinforces Importance of Meeting Your Deadlines

Our associates in Israel, Reinhold Cohn & Partners, reported on a recent Israeli court decision pertaining to a missed national stage filing deadline. In the case of Mindcake LLC vs. Registrar of Patents, the Tel Aviv District Court refused the appeal from the Registrar’s decision to deny late national stage entry into Israel, ruling that the applicant did not meet the requisite standard of due care. Generally speaking, many patent offices will allow a missed filing deadline if the applicant can show that the failure to timely file occurred in spite of all due care being exercised by the applicant and its legal counsel.

Jeff Shieh 133x200 2

Without going into the details of this particular case, the court found that by failing to respond to the Israeli counsel’s request for instructions, the US counsel had not met the requisite due care standard. And even though the application missed the 30-month deadline by merely 2 days, the court ruled that the length of the delay was irrelevant in their analysis. As a result, the PCT application was denied entry into Israel.

This case further stresses the importance of monitoring and meeting your patent deadlines. We speak with applicants all the time who underestimate the consequences of not filing in time. Actions, such as publishing your invention in a trade journal or filing a provision application, can have serious international ramifications. We hear from many inventors who say they’re delaying filing until they are “ready” to proceed. Often times, the clock is already ticking and it doesn’t stop just because the inventor’s not ready.

Want more information on the national/regional stage filing deadlines for PCT applications? Download a copy of our PCT national phase guide which provides specific filing details for 45 popular jurisdictions.


Related insights